In June this year, the Department for Education published its Enduring Relationships Strategy. It includes a new measure to track the quality of each child’s relationships while they are in care and after they leave. The minister, Josh MacAlister, told the Commons why: “what gets measured is often the thing that gets done.” Much of the measure’s design has not yet been settled, which makes this a good time to ask what we think it should capture. Drawing on my PhD research on Independent Visitors, I argue that we should value relationships for children in care, as we would for any child, as an end in themselves, not as a means to other ends.

A relationship with no defined outcome
Independent Visitors (IVs) are volunteer befrienders matched with children in care long term. Every looked-after child has the right to be considered for one, yet only around 3% of children in care in England have an IV, and just 1% in Wales. My study drew on Q methodology and interviews with 82 participants, including 20 young people with an IV.
Participants did not agree on whether IV was designed to achieve outcomes at all. One coordinator said: “The goal, if there is a goal, is just the relationship in itself.” But others, particularly Independent Reviewing Officers, described IV support in terms of what it might lead to: self-esteem, social skills, healthier relationships in adulthood. Young people mostly did not. They valued having a trusted adult outside the care system, but rarely saw this in terms of outcomes. For some, what mattered was the freedom to build a relationship with a trusted adult that was not designed to achieve anything: “What I want is to do what we both want and enjoy it together. I just want to go out. Have fun. And that’s it. Not be thinking about achieving goals” (Lewis, 14).
Why the distinction matters
First, a relationship justified by its outcomes is a conditional one. If we value a child’s relationship with a youth worker or a friend’s parent because it improves attendance, we imply that one that does not is worth less. I am not claiming that relationships make no difference to outcomes. If better outcomes follow, so much the better. But a relationship should not have to earn its place by producing them. Children in care already know a lot about support that is conditional and tied to a plan. Non-professional relationships, like those IVs provide, matter precisely because they are not.
Second, outcome measures may miss the value inherent in relationship-based support. There is little reason to expect IV, seen once a month, to change most young people’s education or health. Yet for some it is a pivotal source of support and connection: my study found it often mattered most to those whose experience of care had been poor. An evaluation of IV built on ‘hard’ outcomes would tell us little about what young people value. What is more, it could push services towards what is easy to count: volunteers steering conversations towards jobs and college, or services prioritising matches with ‘easier’ children.
What this means for the new measure
In my thesis I argued that we should measure connection rather than change: the quality and stability of a young person’s relationships, not proxy outcomes such as wellbeing or attainment. Recording who matters to a child, and asking children to define who counts, whether family, friends, neighbours or teachers, is a step in the right direction. It treats a child’s relationships as worth knowing about in their own right, not only as a route to something else. But how the measure is designed will determine whether it delivers on that, or becomes a metric built around what is easy to count.
The strategy describes a practice-based measure that helps practitioners have “meaningful conversations” with children so they can define and record their relationships. But it is not enough simply to count the people a child names. A child may name a grandparent they have not seen for two years, or a former foster carer they have lost touch with. A list tells us who a child feels connected to, not whether those relationships are active, reliable or likely to last. A useful measure would need to capture how often children see these people, whether they can rely on them, and whether the relationships survive placement moves and leaving care.
What happens when a child has few people?
In the Lords, a peer asked whether children who score lower would get more support. This is where the measure could be most useful. A child who names few people, or few who they actually see, is exactly the child my research suggests stands to gain most from an IV. Used at the level of the individual child, the measure could prompt practitioners to offer a range of support, including an IV. The strategy does not mention IVs, yet they are a statutory entitlement that already exists to provide the kind of relationship it describes, and one that currently reaches very few children. If the measure is to treat relationships as an end in themselves, it should be judged not by the scores it produces but by whether children with few people around them end up with more.
Further reading
Department for Education (2026) Enduring Relationships Strategy
